SPB 1905 ALL-STAR BALLOT

---

First place votes are worth 5 points, Second place votes are worth 3 points & Third place votes are worth 1 point
Position Qualification: Catchers: Min 236 Plate Appearances      All others Min 330 Plate Appearances
    Players are listed at the positions that they played most during the SPB season.
Starter Qualification: Min 14 or more wins
Reliever Qualification: Min 1 or more saves or Min 20 appearances with an ERA of 3.50 or below

---

Note - Although this screen cannot stop you, please do not cast multiple ballots for the same player (i.e. 1st,2nd & 3rd). The duplicated votes will be discarded in the process of tallying the total votes.

---

Manager Name:

Team Name:

American League- Catcher
Name	Team	AVG	OBP	SLG	AB	H	2B	3B	HR	R	RBI	BB	SO	SB	1st	2nd	3rd
Ossee Schreckengost	Elk	.276	.278	.322	397	109	13	3	0	26	36	2	42	4
Admiral Schlei	NW	.233	.289	.318	352	82	15	3	3	30	35	26	34	5
Roger Bresnahan	Ham	.317	.413	.400	331	105	23	2	0	57	45	43	31	10
Billy Sullivan	LA	.194	.231	.285	270	52	10	3	3	28	25	13	39	13
Mike Heydon	Det	.179	.241	.246	268	48	4	4	2	28	31	21	27	7
Ed McFarland	Fra	.286	.337	.345	253	72	11	2	0	29	23	18	15	5
Tom Needham	LA	.217	.294	.249	253	55	5	0	1	21	18	22	38	1
Heinie Peitz	Tol	.177	.243	.243	248	44	10	0	2	22	23	18	10	0
Red Dooin	Det	.252	.264	.306	246	62	11	1	0	16	30	4	8	9
Lou Criger	Fra	.215	.306	.257	237	51	4	3	0	24	19	27	33	4
Lew Drill	Ham	.243	.351	.308	211	51	9	1	1	29	30	29	26	7

American League- 1stBasemen
Name	Team	AVG	OBP	SLG	AB	H	2B	3B	HR	R	RBI	BB	SO	SB	1st	2nd	3rd
Harry Davis	LA	.249	.282	.362	574	143	37	11	2	71	52	23	59	29
Kitty Bransfield	Elk	.232	.266	.306	568	132	18	7	3	55	50	23	51	25
Fred Tenney	Tol	.301	.366	.376	558	168	21	4	4	90	57	54	15	14
Jiggs Donahue	Det	.291	.366	.380	521	151	26	6	3	82	63	60	75	40
Jake Stahl	Ham	.237	.289	.342	502	119	21	5	7	72	71	18	83	18
Dan McGann	Fra	.338	.424	.473	469	158	20	19	2	81	79	54	30	29
Doc Gessler	NW	.324	.416	.408	431	139	20	4	3	57	62	51	12	25

American League- 2ndBasemen
Name	Team	AVG	OBP	SLG	AB	H	2B	3B	HR	R	RBI	BB	SO	SB	1st	2nd	3rd
Charlie Hickman	Fra	.251	.282	.365	561	141	36	8	4	63	90	16	85	5
Harry Gleason	Elk	.197	.241	.253	517	102	7	9	1	39	44	26	53	4
Jimmy Williams	LA	.172	.240	.258	436	75	10	6	5	36	43	36	58	13
Billy Gilbert	Det	.281	.338	.317	372	104	10	2	0	46	44	30	34	25
Harry Arndt	Tol	.237	.288	.316	348	82	7	3	5	31	40	22	38	9
Frank Isbell	Det	.345	.375	.485	336	116	15	10	4	59	45	13	29	15

American League- 3rdBasemen
Name	Team	AVG	OBP	SLG	AB	H	2B	3B	HR	R	RBI	BB	SO	SB	1st	2nd	3rd
Bill Bradley	Tol	.260	.309	.343	550	143	43	1	0	78	46	21	57	30
Art Devlin	LA	.243	.325	.296	513	124	20	4	0	62	33	48	49	39
Jimmy Collins	Det	.275	.332	.331	501	137	15	7	0	50	67	37	36	19
Dave Brain	Fra	.221	.258	.318	461	102	26	6	2	43	49	17	37	13
Hunter Hill	NW	.220	.273	.246	398	87	8	0	1	29	49	27	66	14
Harry Wolverton	Elk	.179	.231	.242	396	71	13	6	0	29	34	15	31	6
Joe Yeager	Ham	.310	.363	.392	361	112	16	5	1	57	51	20	43	11
Lee Tannehill	Ham	.236	.319	.274	328	77	11	1	0	37	37	38	48	7

American League- Shortstops
Name	Team	AVG	OBP	SLG	AB	H	2B	3B	HR	R	RBI	BB	SO	SB	1st	2nd	3rd
Ed Abbaticchio	Det	.269	.317	.352	605	163	23	12	1	89	53	31	48	39
Bobby Wallace	Tol	.280	.321	.374	596	167	24	13	2	65	89	30	81	18
Charley O'Leary	NW	.231	.268	.271	535	123	14	1	2	55	50	25	52	18
Tommy Corcoran	Fra	.207	.252	.278	520	107	15	8	2	48	52	26	61	32
Phil Lewis	LA	.225	.263	.243	422	95	7	0	0	35	43	17	33	6
Joe Cassidy	Ham	.201	.243	.247	413	83	10	3	1	43	31	17	51	16
Kid Elberfeld	Elk	.245	.307	.305	367	90	16	3	0	38	25	17	49	5

American League- LeftFielders
Name	Team	AVG	OBP	SLG	AB	H	2B	3B	HR	R	RBI	BB	SO	SB	1st	2nd	3rd
George Stone	Fra	.316	.375	.440	620	196	26	10	10	116	75	53	48	25
Jesse Burkett	Ham	.276	.355	.384	572	157	17	15	5	88	93	67	21	11
Sam Mertes	Tol	.285	.349	.435	560	159	41	17	3	92	97	48	51	54
Fred Clarke	Elk	.294	.357	.396	520	153	22	11	3	62	62	51	29	6
Matty McIntyre	LA	.274	.352	.339	466	127	16	6	1	67	55	53	56	12
Danny Hoffman	NW	.270	.321	.351	463	125	10	12	1	75	47	32	48	55
John Anderson	Det	.300	.335	.378	452	135	20	8	0	56	72	24	19	26

American League- CenterFielders
Name	Team	AVG	OBP	SLG	AB	H	2B	3B	HR	R	RBI	BB	SO	SB	1st	2nd	3rd
Roy Thomas	Ham	.310	.410	.343	551	170	10	3	1	104	42	92	49	27
Fielder Jones	Det	.273	.362	.343	545	149	14	9	2	77	48	71	20	11
Homer Smoot	Tol	.309	.361	.467	543	168	28	15	9	86	79	40	42	25
Topsy Hartsel	NW	.308	.425	.394	538	165	24	10	1	109	38	107	48	78
Harry Bay	Fra	.296	.353	.369	523	155	15	10	1	87	43	45	51	58
Rip Cannell	Elk	.225	.293	.264	519	116	14	2	1	45	32	48	39	5
Ginger Beaumont	LA	.284	.323	.405	380	108	13	6	7	48	37	20	23	12

American League- RightFielders
Name	Team	AVG	OBP	SLG	AB	H	2B	3B	HR	R	RBI	BB	SO	SB	1st	2nd	3rd
George Browne	LA	.278	.311	.350	528	147	19	8	1	66	58	21	46	14
Cozy Dolan	NW	.262	.307	.316	522	136	17	6	0	58	58	32	30	25
Elmer Flick	Ham	.290	.383	.425	493	143	20	23	0	81	68	63	51	27
Harry Lumley	Fra	.316	.376	.447	489	154	32	10	4	70	81	48	24	22
Kip Selbach	Tol	.233	.333	.309	427	99	9	3	6	55	55	64	28	16
Emil Frisk	Elk	.235	.331	.279	419	98	12	2	1	47	35	50	32	6
Jim Jackson	Det	.230	.292	.286	411	94	12	4	1	50	50	31	54	11
Otis Clymer	Det	.274	.328	.331	352	96	11	3	1	49	46	27	36	31

American League- Starting Pitchers
Name	Team	W-L	ERA	GS	CG	SHO	INN	R/9	OPS	RS/G	1st	2nd	3rd
Vic Willis	Det	23-14	2.58	40	28	3	341. 2	11.0	.581	4.6
George Mullin	Det	24-10	2.22	41	25	3	340. 2	11.2	.590	4.9
Frank Owen	Det	23-14	2.05	38	27	3	329. 0	9.3	.553	3.6
Rube Waddell	Fra	28-7	1.63	35	27	3	325. 2	9.5	.558	3.7
Jack Chesbro	Elk	23-14	2.23	38	29	4	323. 0	9.7	.570	3.7
Harry Howell	LA	15-17	2.82	37	25	0	315. 2	11.1	.607	3.8
Christy Mathewson	LA	16-19	2.70	36	24	5	306. 2	10.1	.581	3.6
Ed Killian	Ham	18-16	3.04	37	26	2	305. 0	12.5	.667	4.8
Cy Young	Tol	22-11	2.53	34	30	3	303. 0	9.1	.560	5.0
Deacon Phillippe	Ham	17-16	2.47	35	25	4	302. 2	10.3	.611	4.4
Doc White	NW	14-13	2.32	35	22	4	299. 0	10.2	.590	3.8
Togie Pittinger	Fra	18-17	3.06	37	22	2	285. 2	11.9	.651	4.6
Addie Joss	Fra	19-8	2.44	34	22	5	276. 1	10.8	.606	4.7
Fred Glade	NW	16-13	2.48	35	20	4	272. 0	10.6	.588	4.8
Andy Coakley	NW	14-17	2.21	34	16	2	269. 0	10.5	.591	3.4
Earl Moore	Ham	15-12	2.48	32	22	3	261. 2	11.6	.618	5.2
Barney Pelty	Tol	21-7	2.24	29	23	5	249. 1	10.6	.572	5.0
Happy Townsend	Det	15-10	2.02	26	16	4	213. 2	9.9	.548	3.7
Chief Bender	Tol	16-12	2.20	23	18	3	212. 2	11.1	.586	3.5

American League- Relief Pitchers
Name	Team	W-L	S	ERA	GR	INN	R/9	OPS	SV%	IR%	1st	2nd	3rd
George Winter	Fra	11-12	2	2.62	23	185. 1	10.5	.597	1.000	.168
Hooks Wiltse	NW	6-11	7	3.07	24	114. 1	11.9	.634	.779	.350
Chick Robitaille	Tol	7-5	4	2.14	13	113. 1	10.6	.603	.668	.500
Weldon Henley	LA	4-5	3	3.51	21	92. 1	10.3	.608	.750	.078
Norwood Gibson	NW	4-2	1	2.84	44	88. 2	13.0	.714	.500	.274
Ambrose Puttmann	LA	0-9	1	3.65	30	86. 1	14.2	.769	.333	.571
Clark Griffith	Det	5-6	4	2.48	16	72. 2	9.4	.523	.800	.268
Fred Mitchell	Ham	1-2	4	2.64	25	71. 2	13.4	.700	.800	.647
Jack Sutthoff	Elk	0-9	2	6.57	29	49. 1	18.4	.936	.500	.476
Dick Harley	Elk	0-2	0	2.14	21	46. 1	9.5	.625	.000	.250
Cy Falkenberg	NW	2-1	0	1.88	23	43. 0	13.6	.636	.000	.500
Patsy Flaherty	Det	3-1	3	5.65	22	43. 0	14.8	.821	1.000	.382
Oscar Jones	Det	3-0	3	1.56	26	40. 1	9.8	.576	.600	.450
Ralph Caldwell	Fra	1-3	4	4.30	18	37. 2	14.8	.833	1.000	.500
Claude Elliott	Elk	0-2	1	5.70	20	30. 0	15.3	.746	1.000	.232
Eddie Cicotte	Elk	1-3	2	2.78	4	22. 2	13.5	.701	1.000	.000

National League- Catcher
Name	Team	AVG	OBP	SLG	AB	H	2B	3B	HR	R	RBI	BB	SO	SB	1st	2nd	3rd
Johnny Kling	Chi	.204	.267	.232	375	76	7	2	0	36	31	32	29	6
Lew Ritter	Hob	.183	.213	.256	275	50	3	7	1	31	29	11	28	20
Mike Grady	NYG	.276	.346	.477	262	72	18	10	5	31	38	24	23	6
Frank Bowerman	Hob	.243	.301	.278	248	60	5	2	0	20	15	13	26	8
John Warner	StL	.300	.345	.433	240	72	7	11	1	27	26	13	13	0
Deacon McGuire	StL	.205	.265	.212	226	46	2	0	0	5	18	11	43	1

National League- 1stBasemen
Name	Team	AVG	OBP	SLG	AB	H	2B	3B	HR	R	RBI	BB	SO	SB	1st	2nd	3rd
Jake Beckley	Chi	.321	.386	.422	504	162	17	12	3	56	64	42	19	15
Hal Chase	Hob	.260	.284	.364	452	117	11	12	4	51	38	8	53	28
Tom Jones	Bkn	.245	.285	.284	447	109	13	1	1	39	49	23	56	2
Shad Barry	NYG	.241	.283	.295	444	107	6	6	2	42	40	23	72	11
Del Howard	StL	.315	.362	.388	411	129	15	6	1	67	57	26	25	20
George Stovall	Bwy	.273	.294	.346	406	111	27	1	0	34	57	9	31	6
Frank Chance	NYR	.317	.448	.412	375	119	10	11	1	93	37	69	36	70

National League- 2ndBasemen
Name	Team	AVG	OBP	SLG	AB	H	2B	3B	HR	R	RBI	BB	SO	SB	1st	2nd	3rd
Kid Gleason	Bwy	.217	.277	.260	580	126	17	2	1	64	41	44	9	22
Miller Huggins	NYG	.222	.346	.279	540	120	13	4	3	82	25	91	36	44
Claude Ritchey	NYR	.237	.318	.312	535	127	25	6	1	60	81	59	43	14
Hobe Ferris	Hob	.206	.237	.304	513	105	15	12	4	40	53	19	69	13
Danny Murphy	StL	.253	.307	.338	497	125	23	7	2	63	61	34	63	6
Germany Schaefer	Bkn	.223	.275	.282	406	90	9	6	1	51	30	29	40	16
Charlie Malay	Bkn	.230	.276	.270	350	80	9	1	1	35	27	21	23	7
Johnny Evers	Chi	.262	.315	.308	334	87	9	2	1	45	25	22	12	19

National League- 3rdBasemen
Name	Team	AVG	OBP	SLG	AB	H	2B	3B	HR	R	RBI	BB	SO	SB	1st	2nd	3rd
Ernie Courtney	NYR	.262	.310	.291	587	153	10	4	0	76	51	35	66	12
Lave Cross	NYG	.258	.288	.315	523	135	19	2	2	32	58	17	20	7
Emil Batch	Chi	.254	.290	.352	519	132	18	13	2	47	60	21	40	19
Doc Casey	Hob	.215	.290	.301	505	108	20	9	2	55	51	47	36	8
Bill Coughlin	Bkn	.270	.324	.348	502	135	22	7	1	65	49	31	75	16
Harry Steinfeldt	Bwy	.250	.294	.355	380	95	15	11	1	41	31	21	37	11
Wid Conroy	StL	.319	.374	.430	365	116	19	8	2	56	38	29	39	30
Jimmy Burke	StL	.242	.279	.288	316	76	7	4	0	28	36	7	35	9

National League- Shortstops
Name	Team	AVG	OBP	SLG	AB	H	2B	3B	HR	R	RBI	BB	SO	SB	1st	2nd	3rd
Terry Turner	NYG	.232	.268	.313	568	131	13	14	2	51	69	18	52	23
George Davis	Chi	.282	.312	.367	552	155	33	4	2	78	69	22	56	27
Honus Wagner	Bwy	.302	.369	.431	549	166	33	8	7	75	66	48	55	44
Freddy Parent	NYR	.227	.264	.272	532	120	14	5	0	44	63	25	61	19
Joe Tinker	Hob	.203	.229	.244	532	108	16	3	0	58	33	16	42	30
Mickey Doolan	Bkn	.260	.289	.361	492	128	27	8	2	58	71	16	68	18
Bill Dahlen	StL	.239	.329	.295	471	112	15	0	4	59	38	48	45	18

National League- LeftFielders
Name	Team	AVG	OBP	SLG	AB	H	2B	3B	HR	R	RBI	BB	SO	SB	1st	2nd	3rd
Sherry Magee	NYG	.258	.309	.395	569	146	21	20	6	78	64	33	66	51
Frank Schulte	Chi	.269	.318	.381	487	131	12	15	4	66	51	30	48	18
Jimmy Sheckard	Bwy	.296	.362	.400	472	139	22	11	2	77	48	42	46	11
Spike Shannon	StL	.246	.309	.297	463	114	12	4	1	56	38	38	39	17
Jim Delahanty	Hob	.253	.308	.333	453	114	12	5	5	55	37	20	43	18
Patsy Dougherty	Bkn	.304	.358	.380	342	104	7	5	3	42	36	24	42	11
Danny Green	NYR	.273	.371	.373	335	91	12	8	2	44	46	45	39	14

National League- CenterFielders
Name	Team	AVG	OBP	SLG	AB	H	2B	3B	HR	R	RBI	BB	SO	SB	1st	2nd	3rd
Mike Donlin	NYR	.410	.451	.584	609	249	41	22	7	123	97	42	54	26
Ben Koehler	Bwy	.241	.281	.299	534	128	19	6	0	53	35	28	52	23
Charlie Jones	Hob	.201	.243	.230	521	104	9	2	1	33	39	24	87	19
Cy Seymour	Bkn	.354	.415	.498	516	182	32	11	7	78	82	51	27	15
Billy Maloney	NYG	.247	.300	.350	514	127	21	13	2	50	38	31	29	42
Tommy Leach	Bwy	.271	.309	.384	494	134	22	15	1	63	58	25	53	11
Chick Stahl	Chi	.281	.363	.350	491	138	11	10	1	79	35	58	48	17
John Dobbs	StL	.261	.322	.331	444	116	15	5	2	60	38	35	28	17
Duff Cooley	Chi	.268	.305	.365	326	87	7	11	1	28	41	16	16	2

National League- RightFielders
Name	Team	AVG	OBP	SLG	AB	H	2B	3B	HR	R	RBI	BB	SO	SB	1st	2nd	3rd
Sam Crawford	StL	.351	.419	.509	552	193	42	11	8	99	96	64	13	19
John Titus	NYR	.279	.374	.393	552	154	36	12	1	89	91	66	34	7
Willie Keeler	Hob	.314	.370	.373	544	171	15	4	3	69	55	44	12	16
Jimmy Slagle	NYG	.241	.353	.316	509	122	17	2	6	82	45	85	46	41
Socks Seybold	Chi	.273	.334	.381	493	134	31	4	5	67	67	38	55	5
Fred Odwell	Bwy	.211	.255	.322	459	97	8	8	9	41	59	20	44	17
Frank Huelsman	Bkn	.226	.302	.338	396	89	21	9	2	53	40	35	64	7
Ike VanZandt	Bkn	.314	.338	.400	390	122	22	3	2	43	45	12	25	6

National League- Starting Pitchers
Name	Team	W-L	ERA	GS	CG	SHO	INN	R/9	OPS	RS/G	1st	2nd	3rd
Irv Young	StL	18-22	2.42	42	33	4	364. 2	10.1	.598	3.0
Eddie Plank	Bkn	22-12	2.28	40	28	6	328. 1	10.4	.604	3.4
Al Orth	Hob	17-15	2.20	36	29	4	303. 1	9.4	.547	3.6
Orval Overall	NYR	15-20	2.96	38	26	2	300. 2	12.2	.643	4.3
Frank Smith	NYG	17-15	2.40	34	30	7	296. 0	10.1	.546	3.4
Tom Hughes	StL	19-9	2.10	33	25	4	287. 1	9.4	.556	4.7
Bob Ewing	StL	19-11	3.39	34	23	4	279. 0	11.2	.636	4.6
Nick Altrock	NYR	19-13	3.74	34	24	1	274. 1	13.1	.737	5.0
Chick Fraser	NYR	16-14	3.61	32	24	2	269. 1	13.1	.688	4.9
Tully Sparks	Chi	14-11	2.33	29	18	2	255. 0	9.6	.565	4.0
Ed Reulbach	NYR	17-13	2.94	30	22	3	254. 1	10.5	.612	4.3
Willie Sudhoff	Hob	17-14	2.18	29	23	4	247. 2	11.1	.621	3.5
Bill Donovan	Bwy	15-14	2.66	31	23	2	244. 0	12.1	.638	4.1
Bob Rhoads	Bwy	16-10	2.32	27	21	0	225. 0	10.8	.607	4.3
Otto Hess	Chi	17-11	2.76	28	19	3	224. 2	11.8	.629	4.5
Frank Corridon	Bwy	14-15	3.26	26	19	2	223. 2	11.0	.616	3.3
Bob Wicker	Bkn	14-9	2.20	22	14	3	180. 1	9.7	.539	4.0

National League- Relief Pitchers
Name	Team	W-L	S	ERA	GR	INN	R/9	OPS	SV%	IR%	1st	2nd	3rd
Red Donahue	Chi	7-8	1	1.57	20	143. 0	10.3	.606	1.000	.300
Bill Hogg	StL	12-3	1	2.40	16	139. 0	11.1	.556	1.000	.212
Big Jeff Pfeffer	NYR	10-2	4	2.12	18	131. 2	10.4	.588	1.000	.468
Rick Adams	Bwy	3-4	3	2.64	36	95. 1	13.8	.692	.600	.560
Jim Buchanan	NYG	1-1	1	2.85	20	60. 0	10.0	.590	.333	.480
Jack Doscher	NYR	1-4	1	3.62	9	49. 2	12.5	.696	.500	.571
Wish Egan	StL	4-4	4	4.39	28	41. 0	13.4	.711	.800	.565
Tom Walker	StL	2-5	3	2.63	15	41. 0	10.9	.653	1.000	.333
Harry Ables	NYR	1-2	1	6.18	9	27. 2	19.2	.967	.333	.444
Gene Ford	Chi	2-0	1	1.69	9	21. 1	12.6	.716	1.000	.250